Time and situations indicate that right before the wonders of Weird New Worlds, the thought of seeing Star Trek Captains Pike and Kirk together was an not likely point. Pike, after all, only existed in the realm of Trek’s authentic pilot, by itself then re-engineered for an episode that without end shut the door on his upcoming on the show. But Odd New Worlds relished its possibility to thrust these two legends with each other.
Check with a Star Trek enthusiast about their favored captain and certain, they might give you a number of noble factors, but they are almost certainly just as very likely to elevate their preference by disparaging the other captains that have led technology immediately after technology of Star Trek reveals. We cannot assist from time to time but envision that, for our select to be as truly great as we believe they are—the perfect of Starfleet—the other captains we’ve satisfied have to be flawed in some way.
So when Bizarre New Worlds’ pleasant initially year finale, “A Excellent of Mercy,” designed the shock transfer of introducing Paul Wesley’s Captain Kirk a small previously than we’d anticipated, I mentally braced myself in a way that amazed me. Was Unusual New Worlds about to do its have hero a minor filthy, now that it could get its palms on the most iconic Star Trek character ever? How would the collection, previously accomplishing so much in its finale, have interaction with the specter of Kirk’s legacy even though placing him up versus the captain we have occur to know and adore about this initially period?
And for just a instant, it just about seemed like “A High quality of Mercy” was going to go there. As the episode’s operate-by of the plot of Trek icon “Balance of Terror” reaches a climax from the typical episode—the Business chasing down its Romulan foe by applying the wake of a comet to see by its cloaking technology—things get a turn for the even worse with Pike in Kirk’s original role, the latter in this alt-retelling of the state of affairs aboard his individual command on the U.S.S. Farragut. Hoodwinked when the Chook of Prey is nowhere to be noticed at the time the two ships navigate all-around the comet, Pike hesitates the place Kirk reacted on instinct in the initial episode—and is duly rewarded for his pause with a surprise assault from the Romulans, just one that cripples the Farragut and leaves the Organization poorly compromised in the approach. Immediately after the needed choice to evacuate the Farragut crew to the Business is produced and Kirk thanks Pike for his guidance, the two share a private communicate in Pike’s quarters… and Kirk goes in on Pike for his hesitation.
It’s the frankest we’ve witnessed a Odd New Worlds hero go against a single of their personal. But crucially, “A Excellent of Mercy” doesn’t address this like a failure for Pike, or maybe just as crucially, that Kirk is in the wrong for wanting to have been far more tactically intense in opposition to the Romulans, as he in the long run is in “Balance.” A lesser episode would’ve either painted Pike’s overriding willingness to discover compromise and provide a tranquil conclude to conflict as a naive flaw, or Kirk’s aggressiveness as a base, impulsive streak that Starfleet officers must increase in opposition to. A lesser episode would’ve certainly built Kirk and Pike’s foil in this regard a wedge of conflict involving them, but fortunately, it is not what we obtained. As an alternative, Kirk and Pike’s respective weaknesses are performed not as this sort of, but as strengths, and the two captains by no means argue about who has the right concept. They’re just both equally great adult males with two unique strategies, and that they’re permitted to co-exist rather of the episode presenting one particular way or the other as the excellent path to success emphasizes that bond of regard we see improve amongst them.
Due to the fact truly, we ultimately see in this new timeline that neither captain’s method labored out. Pike’s desire to bring the Romulans to the table and negotiate a peace not noticed for a hundred decades is noble, but it stops him from currently being as tactically minded as Kirk in functioning out the Romulan ship’s targets. And even while he will come so close to discovering widespread ground for the Federation and the Star Empire to construct on, his system could never ever account for the actuality that there’s a complete bunch of other Romulans aboard that ship ready and ready to start out a combat. Even Kirk, who performs up his aggressive strategies by marshaling a fleet of remote mining vessels to act as Federation backup when Romulan reinforcements get there, can’t locate an opening from the overpowering aggression of the Praetor and her forces. Both equally men’s belief in the way out of their predicament hits up in opposition to a wall in that often, points just aren’t likely to go the way you prepared, and at times failure is likely to be the only choice. The Business and Kirk escape terribly wounded, but the Romulans are victorious, and emboldened to begin a war with the Federation that, need to this timeline persist, claim the lives of billions.
And nevertheless even with that, Pike and Kirk section strategies at the stop of “A Quality of Mercy” with a sober respect for just about every other. As brash and as sore a loser as we could characterize Jim Kirk in our heads as often, he in no way gloats to Pike in their demure farewell that his way would’ve worked. Pike alike by no means lambasts Kirk above the fact that his aggressive tactical acumen provided as well very little, far too late, or escalated the problem to the stage it broke as bad as it did. They settle for that the other simply had distinctive thoughts with benefit, and share a regret that they did not get a chance to get to know each and every other quicker beyond an practically no-acquire situation like the 1 they found themselves in.
In accomplishing so, Peculiar New Worlds navigated just one of its most significant proverbial elephants in the home with aplomb. Who requires Pike vs. Kirk when you could only just have the both of those of them?
Want much more io9 information? Check out out when to assume the hottest Marvel and Star Wars releases, what is following for the DC Universe on film and Television, and everything you have to have to know about Property of the Dragon and Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Electric power.